Hi Jamie,
Thanks for all that, I hope it helped to "get it out of your system." I wonder if we would make similar conceptual errors if we were teaching a biology unit???
I'm certainly glad that you had your wits about you (as I expected). This must have been incredibly frustrating and it shows the learning trap that goes with practice teaching. We always assume the associate knows all the right answers. It would appear that your associate is playing with mumb-jumbo.
I think the line that really caught my attention was the one you flagged:
A battery can deliver 1500J of energy to 100C of charge. How much current passes through in 5 seconds and what is the voltage.
Shouldn't it be something like "if a battery does 1500J of work on 100C of charge, what is the voltage?" and then "if 100C of charge passes a point in 5 seconds, what is the current?"
In this case I think venting was both essential and productive!!
You are reminding me of what can be so dangerous about elementary teachers often having such limited understanding of math and science. (someone mentioned to me that a math class is debating whether children should use calculators while learning math).
Yes, the water analogy can be helpful, but I think it really requires showing the differences as well as the similarities--and also asking the students if the analogy helps them BUT emphasizing that it's most important to remember that they are very different phenomena--just one is much easier to observe and connect to from everyday experience.
I'm glad you are so attentive to the students' misconceptions and the things they cannot explain. it might be interesting to put the 3 batteries question on a quiz--I bet many of them won't remember the right answer, and it would be interesting to ask them to explain their answers!!
I'm very grateful that you typed so much and thought of me as you struggled (suffered?). I look forward to discussing it in person in January!
Keep up the good work!
Tom
No comments:
Post a Comment