Hi Tom,
To start with, I have a couple replies to questions/comments in your comments on my poster. First off, thanks for your compliments on my writing. I often struggle to put pen to paper/fingers to keyboard, and it's nice to have the encouragement. I find that many people who go into sciences are at least slightly of the mindset of avoiding having to write essays, just as many people in the arts are there to avoid math. I wonder if anyone in the languages is approaching those subjects from the same perspective as Knight: why is writing so intimidating for some people, and how can we get across the key concepts without overwhelming students with really technical details. It's been great practice for me writing this blog, and it's great to get into the habit of recording my thoughts on what I'm teaching. The daily lesson analysis has been great for that too.
3 associates has been great. Any challenges have been offset by having a more balanced day. My afternoon has been prep, and then shop class (building paddles). It's so nice to get out of the classroom for half the day, and it makes me appreciate the value of having a balance in a classroom between listening time, speaking with partners/small groups, and body break/moving around time. Since there isn't much prep for the shop class, I feel like I only have to co-ordinate with two associates, and I feel that I've been balancing those classes well. I haven't loved all my lessons, but have kept Eric Finn's message in mind, and tried to focus on the value of recording what I didn't like in order to improve my teaching in the future.
One lesson that comes to mind is my physics lesson from Friday. In an effort to make my lesson on power more accessible, I tried to use an analogy of trucks dropping off boxes. The rate of trucks dropping boxes off represents the current, and the number of boxes per truck represents potential difference (so a truck is like a coulomb of charge, and a box is like a joule of energy). Then the rate of boxes being dropped off is (rate of trucks)*(boxes per truck)= rate of boxes being dropped off OR I*deltaV=P......this analogy made sense to me (and still does), but I'm not sure it was necessary, and I feel that is just confused students more. In retrospect, I'm not so sure about approaching power from that concept (P=IV). I'm thinking it might be better to just look at P=E/t, and bring in the connection to current and voltage after. I'd be interested in looking into this more. I don't feel like I had the concept of power down until I started prepping for this lesson, and I didn't find much in Knight on how to approach it.
In terms of overall class structure, there's a few things I've been doing in that class that I wouldn't want to do in my own class (in the name of not stirring the pot too much with my AT, as well as not killing myself redesigning lessons, I've been doing things more or less how she does them).
-I hate writing notes on the board
-I feel like when I teach the concept of something like voltage, and then follow that up by handing out a worksheet on V=E/Q problems that I'm sending the wrong message. Really what students end up "learning" is how to do algebra, not physics.
-I'm not creating a collaborative learning environment. My AT really stresses individual work, even with practice worksheets, and feels that any shared work will mean that struggling students will do nothing.
Ok, again I feel like I'm writing quite a lot...one more thing. I think I've missed the last couple days of daily lesson analysis, they've been a bit hectic. I haven't managed to separate students based on their preference for sitting and note taking, or being actively involved, but I did a 2 station rotation on thursday and friday. Each day, one station involved using the laptops to find information on the internet (flights on thursday, kijiji rideshares on friday), and calculating associated costs based on this information. The other station had almost no writing or hard math skills, and was more active. On thursday I brought my bike and gear for a road trip, and had students explore it, discuss the uses of various parts, and then guess costs of all the gear. On friday students played a memory card game about CAA.
For the most part I really liked how this worked, and that we were able to use the presence of two teachers (my AT and I) to our advantage. One student, however, JY, has a lot of anxiety problems. He generally sits in the back corner, and doesn't speak at all, except in a whisper one on one. He didn't want to join either of the stations, and this structure took away his option of a "safer"space in the back corner. More hands on activities are more difficult to adapt to a student who needs to sit on his own silently. A goal for the future is to find ways to a) Give someone like JY the a way to sit on his own and work through material by himself and b) expand his comfort zone in social situations by easing him into these more social lessons.
Thanks so much for reading, and for your thoughtful replies, and the incredible amount of dedication you have to this course.
Jamie
No comments:
Post a Comment